Critics hit elitism of White House summit

The White House higher education summit sidelined community colleges and other institutions serving low-income students, complain critics, reports Katherine Mangan in the Chronicle of Higher Education.

Most were excited that the issues they’d long grappled with were taking center stage. But some couldn’t help pointing out that many ideas emerging from the White House summit—targeted scholarships, better test preparation, summer enrichment programs, fast-tracked remedial education—were old news on their campuses, which nonetheless continue to see low completion rates.

More than 100 colleges made the guest list. Only 10 community colleges participated, even though most lower-income college students attend community colleges.

Colleges had to commit to new efforts to serve needy students, said Patricia A. McGuire, president of Trinity Washington University. “If you’re an institution like us, where 80 percent of the students are eligible for Pell Grants and the median family income is $25,000, there’s hardly any room to do anything new or more than we’re already doing.”

Much of the discussion at the White House meeting was about the phenomenon of “undermatching,” in which many high-achieving, low-income students who would qualify for admission to selective colleges instead end up at institutions that are beneath them academically, and typically have lower graduation rates. More-selective colleges, the thinking goes, tend to offer better support—small classes, tutoring—to students unfamiliar with the demands of college.

Not surprisingly, many educators bristle at the suggestion that the colleges that enroll most of the nation’s low-income and underrepresented students aren’t up to the task.

Achieving the Dream, which focuses on raising community college completion rates, committed to dedicating a day of its annual institute to workshops on helping the least-prepared students. “While our colleges have been working for a long time to try to improve outcomes, they’ve deepened their commitment in light of the call from the White House,” said Carol A. Lincoln, senior vice president at Achieving the Dream.

College leaders were “inspired” by the summit, reports the Chronicle in another story.


POSTED BY Joanne Jacobs ON January 20, 2014

Comments & Trackbacks (1) | Post a Comment

[…] Obama’s White House summit on higher education sidelined community colleges and other non-elite institutions, critics charge. Most lower-income college students enroll in community colleges, which already are […]

Your email is never published nor shared.

Required
Required